01What Mailchimp can't do alone
Mailchimp is an outbound tool. It sends on a schedule, or when something changes on your list. What it can't see is what happens at the moment of payment: a donor who starts checkout and leaves, a monthly gift that fails, or the right point in someone's giving to ask for more.
Sources: GoCardless Payment Success Index (2020); Baymard Institute.
The fix is a donation and payment layer that acts on those moments and feeds the results back into Mailchimp. That's SmartRaise.
02The two-system stack
The rule of thumb: Mailchimp handles scheduled, broadcast communication. SmartRaise handles everything triggered by a payment event.
| Mailchimp | SmartRaise | |
|---|---|---|
| Sends to | Your whole list or segments | Individual donors |
| Triggered by | Dates, sign-ups, tags, behaviour | Payments, failures, abandonment, subscription changes |
| Knows about | Engagement, segments, list data | Live payment state, amounts, recurring status |
| Key jobs | Appeals, newsletters, welcome series, stewardship | Thank-yous (often used as membership welcomes), abandoned checkout, failed payments, upgrades, cancellation recovery |
| Data direction | Receives data from SmartRaise | Pushes donor and commerce data to Mailchimp |
Every donation pushes the donor's name, email, address, phone, opt-in status, amount, frequency, payment method and campaign tags into Mailchimp. Donations arrive as orders and donors as customers in Mailchimp Commerce. That unlocks segment conditions like amount spent in total and purchase date, and pre-built segments such as Recent, First-time and Lapsed Customers.
03Data, tags and campaign setup
What syncs, and what doesn't
Once the Commerce sync is live, SmartRaise sends email, first and last name, amount, date, frequency, payment method and form tags automatically. History from before the integration doesn't sync, so import each contact's most recent gift date and amount as custom audience fields before your first segmented send.
Before you send anything, check three things:
- Every contact has an explicit email opt-in on record.
- The
FNAMEfield has a default value, so a blank name never produces an empty greeting. - A real test donation shows up as an order on a contact profile.
Technical setup
Your technical team authorises your domain (Globals > Authorisation), applies branding (Globals > Branding), registers a custom send address and sets up SPF and DKIM DNS records. Email hello@brandresponse.cc and we'll walk you through it.
Audience structure
Use one audience. Several audiences block cross-segment sends and split your reporting. Inside it, use tags for facts and attribution (SmartRaise pushes these in), groups for subscriber-facing preferences, and saved segments for targeting.
A tag dictionary
Name tags [category]-[descriptor]-[year], lowercase, hyphens only.
| Tag | When it's applied |
|---|---|
appeal-winter-2026 | Winter fundraising appeal |
appeal-emergency-2026 | Emergency or crisis appeal |
appeal-eoy-2026 | End-of-year giving push |
donor-recurring | All monthly or yearly donors |
donor-oneoff | All one-off donors |
donor-lapsed | 12+ months with no gift |
donor-new | First gift |
donor-upgraded | Accepted an upgrade ask |
track-welcome | Entered the welcome journey |
track-reactivation | In the lapsed-donor sequence |
track-major-prospect | Flagged for major donor cultivation |
src-email · src-social · src-web-organic · src-partner | Where the donation came from |
Setting up an appeal in seven steps
- Create the campaignCampaigns > Create campaign > Email > Regular email, with a clear internal name such as “Winter Appeal 2026 – Existing Donors”.
- Pick recipientsBuild a segment: tag is
donor-oneoff, tag is notdonor-recurring, purchase activity within the last 365 days. Save it for reuse. - Campaign infoSend from a named person, which tends to beat an organisation name for appeals. Write the subject last, under 50 characters, and let the preview text continue it rather than summarise it.
- TrackingTurn on opens, clicks and e-commerce link tracking, and add
utm_source=mailchimp,utm_medium=emailandutm_campaign=winter-appeal-2026. - Build the emailGenerate the HTML with the SmartRaise Mailchimp email builder and paste it into Mailchimp's “Code your own” editor.
- ScheduleTuesday or Wednesday mornings usually do best, but check against your own data.
- Tag respondentsUse a Customer Journey triggered by “clicked any link in this campaign” to tag people who engaged but didn't give, so you can follow up.

The email builder takes your brand colour, form, copy and an impact line per amount, and returns mobile-friendly HTML with a personalised greeting (*|FNAME|* with a fallback), a donate button per amount, a secondary monthly giving link and the unsubscribe and preferences footer.
04Building a form that converts
- Amount buttonsShow four to six amounts and pre-select a default. If your average gift is £15, pre-selecting £25 nudges it up.
- FrequencyPre-select monthly and add a short nudge underneath, such as “Most supporters choose monthly to create steady, year-round impact.”
- Payment methodLead with Direct Debit and show card as a smaller link beneath it. Turn on Instant Bank Pay through GoCardless for faster GBP payments.
- FieldsKeep it to first name, last name, email and email opt-in. Use hidden fields to record values like
utm_campaignfrom the URL, and conditional fields to ask for more only when it's relevant. - Fee coveringLet donors cover the processing fee with one tick.
05Segmentation in Mailchimp
Under E-commerce activity, Mailchimp lets you segment on amount spent in total, amount per order, purchase date and total number of orders. Start with its pre-built segments (Audience > Segments) and rename them in nonprofit language, for example “Recent donors” instead of “Recent customers”.

| Segment | Conditions | Use it for |
|---|---|---|
| Active recurring donors | Tag is donor-recurring | Leave out of one-off asks; send impact updates |
| Mid-tier donors | Amount spent in total > £250 | Upgrade asks and stewardship |
| Major donor prospects | Amount spent in total > £1,000, or amount per order > £500 | Personal cultivation, not mass sends |
| Deeply lapsed | Has purchased, but not in the last 18 months | A dedicated re-engagement track |
| Engaged non-donors | Opened the last 5 emails, has not purchased | A first-gift campaign |
| By appeal | Tag contains appeal-winter-2026 | Follow-up and attribution |
On Mailchimp's Free and Essentials plans the segment builder allows five conditions per segment. Standard and above allows unlimited nested conditions, which you'll need for RFM (recency, frequency, monetary) segments.
06Writing appeals that convert
Open with something concrete (a person, a place or a number), make an ask in proportion to it, and put one clear button near the top. One story, one ask, one button.
Prefilled links
Merge-tagged links take readers to a form with their name, email, amount, frequency and payment method already filled in, one click from paying.

https://cms.smartraise.net/yourform?email=*|EMAIL|*&firstName=*|FNAME|*&lastName=*|LNAME|*&amount=25&frequency=monthly&method=gocardless&tab=2&tags=winter-2026,src-email
| Parameter | What it does |
|---|---|
email=*|EMAIL|* | Fills in the email address |
firstName=*|FNAME|* | Fills in the first name |
amount=25 | Pre-selects £25 |
frequency=monthly | Pre-selects monthly |
method=gocardless | Pre-selects Direct Debit |
tab=2 | Skips straight to the payment step |
tags=winter-2026 | Tags the donation for attribution in Mailchimp Commerce |
A different link for each segment
| Segment | Parameters |
|---|---|
| First-time donors | ?amount=35&frequency=one-off&tab=2&tags=winter-2026,new-donor |
| Active one-off donors | ?amount=50&frequency=one-off&tab=2&tags=winter-2026,oneoff-active |
| Lapsed donors | ?amount=25&tab=2&tags=winter-2026,reactivation |
| Mid-tier donors | ?amount=100&tab=2&tags=winter-2026,mid-tier |
For recurring donors, use SmartRaise's upgrade flow instead of a prefilled link, so their existing gift goes up rather than a second monthly payment starting.
07The automation layer
These run in SmartRaise under Emails and Nudge automations, triggered by payment events Mailchimp never sees.

| Automation | Trigger | What it does |
|---|---|---|
| Thank-you emails | New one-off gift or new subscription | Separate, editable templates for one-off and recurring |
| Abandoned checkout | Checkout started but not finished within 24 hours | Brings the donor back with amount, name and email filled in |
| Failed payment recovery | A payment fails after all retries | Three emails (straight away, +5 days, +15 days), each with a one-click update link |
| Upgrade flow | Every 6 months per recurring donor | Four tiered emails with one-click upgrade buttons |
| Cancellation and resubscribe | A subscription is cancelled | Offers to carry on at 75%, 50%, 25% or 10% of the previous gift |
Upgrade tiers
| Current gift | Suggested amounts |
|---|---|
| Under £5 a month | £5, £10, £20, £50 |
| £5–£9.99 a month | £10, £20, £50 |
| £10–£19.99 a month | £20, £50 |
| £20–£49.99 a month | £50, £100 |
On the Mailchimp side, build a welcome series in Customer Journey Builder (Standard and above), triggered when a contact is added or tagged: a welcome straight away, an impact story on day 3 and a gentle first-gift ask on day 7.
08Tracking and attribution
Put UTMs on every link (utm_source=mailchimp, utm_medium=email, utm_campaign=winter-2026) so Google Analytics can attribute revenue. Use the SmartRaise tags parameter for donation-level attribution that flows into Mailchimp Commerce, and hidden utm_source and utm_campaign fields so every donation keeps its source. With e-commerce tracking on, Mailchimp campaign reports show total revenue, average order value and who gave.

Review six numbers every month:
- Average gift sizeSplit by one-off and monthly.
- Recurring conversion rateThe share of donors who choose monthly.
- Abandoned checkout recovery rate
- Failed payment recovery rate
- Upgrade uptakeThe share of recurring donors who accept an upgrade.
- Lapsed recovery rateThe share of lapsed donors who give again after re-engagement.
09Testing and iterating
Change one thing per test. Mailchimp's A/B testing (Essentials and above) covers subject line, from name, content and send time, and picks a winner for you. Start with the variables that move money most: the ask amount, the default frequency and the copy on the first screen. Small lists rarely reach significance, so combine results across campaigns, and review segments, automations, average gift and channel mix every quarter.
10Your 30/60/90-day plan
Days 1–30: foundation
- Authorise your domain, apply branding, register your send address and set up SPF and DKIM.
- Confirm the Commerce sync with a test donation.
- Set the form's default amount, turn on fee covering and the frequency nudge, de-emphasise card and add hidden UTM fields.
- Edit the thank-you emails into your own voice.
- Switch on abandoned checkout and failed payment automations.
Days 31–60: segments and appeals
- Rename the pre-built e-commerce segments and build the core custom segments.
- Send your first segment-specific appeal with prefilled links, starting with two variants: active one-off and lapsed.
- Check SmartRaise tags appear in Mailchimp Commerce and segment filters.
Days 61–90: automations and iteration
- Build a welcome series in Customer Journey Builder.
- Switch on the upgrade flow and tailor the resubscribe flow.
- Run your first A/B test on a variable that matters.
- Compare the six core numbers month on month, and book a quarterly review.
Further reading from Mailchimp: advanced segmentation, conditional merge tags, Customer Journey Builder and purchase activity segments. Questions? hello@brandresponse.cc.